Tuesday, May 02, 2006

moratorium

I propose a ban on the use of the word 'gentrification' when describing the displacement of D.C. residents by upper-middle class professionals in certain neighborhoods. Gentrification makes me think of 'landed' gentry ... like before women's and black suffrage, in the initial years of American democracy where only the 'landed gentry' could elect the leaders of our great country. It smacks of elitism, oversimplification of the problem, patronization, and for some reason interjects horrible memories of the L.A. riots inspired by the beating of Rodney King. People who use the word gentrification seem to think of themselves as 'gentry,' and I despise it because it accredits someone who is allegedly well educated some kind of superiority over another human being. So I guess all that education couldn't lead the DC 'gentry' to think critically of how all the resume bullets have inflated themselves to what they despised in Virginia and Maryland (namely self-segregation and homogeneity) and inspired them to move into the real, in-your-face, multi-ethnic, multi-age, myriad of experience, uber-diversified community we know as D.C.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

Sorry, I'm gonna have to comment on this one: Give me a break.

A word that seems to sound like another doesn't imply a multitude of social behaviors that go along with it, including the self-labeling of one as "gentry". It does however suggest proper use of American English diction.

I would content, this is not elitism, oversimplification or patronization. This is capitalism, urban renewal, demographic shifting and a general running out of space. One does not need to be educated nor intelligent to take part in it or to use the word that accurately describes it.
-0

Ex-Bureauqette said...

I see your point anonymous, however, just so I made sure I wasn't completely emotional in my response, I looked up 'gentrification' on dictionary.com: and it says:

"The restoration and upgrading of deteriorated urban property by middle-class or affluent people, often resulting in displacement of lower-income people."

There are certainly people who moved to D.C. in hopes of feeling more like a community (or other equally important reasons)--I generalize ... and there's a subset who are happy to see the 13th Street Market go away, and probably won't cry too hard when Union Mission moves further away from D.C.

You're always welcome to disagree but connotation is just as important in the English language, think how 'gentrification' sounds to those who scrawl 'go home yuppies' on the sidewalk.

Chopin Girl said...

Dude, it is what it is. And I'm definitely coming at it from a very emotional point of view... all of a sudden, people take interest in the city when a good percentage of highly educated folks are now in the city; but for us in the ghetto, no one seemed to care. That's how it looks to us over in Anacostia.

I'm coming at it from both sides and I sympathize with both (and your point, Ms. Kneepains), but the reality is that it is what it is... if you're a yuppie coming in, you've gotta be willing to take the hits of people scrawling on walls "Shaw Yuppies go home". If you are from the ghetto, you have to realize that this stuff happens ALL THE TIME and just roll with it since there tends to be less power in stopping it. I've come to grips with it all... I know that DC's gonna become a dump again when I'm 80 and when my grandkids are 25, it's going to redevelop to something really cool and hip. It's a big ole cycle, there's going to be another name for it other than gentrification, but it won't stop the change from happening.

Chopin Girl said...

Dude, it is what it is. And I'm definitely coming at it from a very emotional point of view... all of a sudden, people take interest in the city when a good percentage of highly educated folks are now in the city; but for us in the ghetto, no one seemed to care. That's how it looks to us over in Anacostia.

I'm coming at it from both sides and I sympathize with both (and your point, Ms. Kneepains), but the reality is that it is what it is... if you're a yuppie coming in, you've gotta be willing to take the hits of people scrawling on walls "Shaw Yuppies go home". If you are from the ghetto, you have to realize that this stuff happens ALL THE TIME and just roll with it since there tends to be less power in stopping it. I've come to grips with it all... I know that DC's gonna become a dump again when I'm 80 and when my grandkids are 25, it's going to redevelop to something really cool and hip. It's a big ole cycle, there's going to be another name for it other than gentrification, but it won't stop the change from happening.

Ex-Bureauqette said...

Just to clarify I'm not putting a moratorium on the change that's occuring in DC because I agree with you its gonna happen ...
although who knows what will happen to all those pretty condos sitting unsold for months ...

just one night turning the word over in my head, I woke up and found I had serious distaste for the word 'gentrification'! :)